Secret Sauce of Storycraft 13.8K subscribers · Aug 21, 2026

If I Could Redo the Hugo Awards || the Final Wugos

Reviews78

Loved

Ender's Game was a little bit more fun, but Blood Music really started the whole idea and concept of nanotechnology, and I think I'm going to give it to Blood Music by Greg Bear.

Loved

This is another transformative book that is so essential to science fiction and what an incredible writer she is. I don't know of anyone else who can put the reader in such an uncomfortable space and yet show you and make you feel everything that the character felt in that situation.

Mixed

While I really did like Diaspora, I felt like there was a little bit of pretentiousness and inaccessibility to Diaspora that I don't think most people would enjoy.

Disliked

Now, this is one that I love this author and I should have liked everything about the summary and the story, but for some reason I just didn't connect with it and I probably need to do a reread of it, but I didn't love this particular one.

Loved

Electric Forest blew me away. The ending of that story recontextualized everything that I read in that whole story and what sounded like a very superficial simple story became a thousand times better, and I was very impressed with it.

Liked

I'm also going to go ahead and cross off Sundiver even though I liked it better than the second book. I seem to have liked it a lot more than a lot of other people, but I don't think it's qualifying for a Hugo this year.

Mixed

This book I have lots of controversial mixed opinions on because some of these ideas were so incredibly mind-blowing. However, the execution was just super opaque and confusing and definitely deals with a reread.

Disliked

Very unpopular opinion, I did not enjoy Shadow of the Torturer, and I don't think that alone, Shadow of the Torturer would qualify as an award. That series is very much its own solid unit or entity, and you have to read the whole thing to really get it.

Mixed

Now, I did like this book, but I found this book to have significantly lost the plot and the promises of the climax to that plot completely. While I found the universe fascinating, for an author to just drop the plot like that was really discombobulating for me.