The only one I think that could replace it that I have already read is 2010: A Space Odyssey because in my opinion, that book was way better than 2001 a Space Odyssey.
If I Could Redo the Hugo Awards || the Final Wugos
Fire Upon the Deep is definitely a classic of science fiction, and it is one that I in particular hold in high esteem.
This one really surprised me. It captured me from the first page. I was interested in the story.
Now, this is one that was an earlier draft, or earlier in the timeline of the series of Vorkosigan, and it was fine. Again, nothing special.
Beyond the Blue Horizon was not good enough to win a Woogo for me, at least. So, it was a little bit more different than the first book, Gateway, but I'm going to kind of cross that one off the list.
Blindness was interesting, but probably not something that would outdo Diamond Age, so I'm going to cross that one off.
Ender's Game was a little bit more fun, but Blood Music really started the whole idea and concept of nanotechnology, and I think I'm going to give it to Blood Music by Greg Bear.
Blue Mars by Kim Stanley Robinson, the third and final book in Kim Stanley Robinson's Mars trilogy, which again, I absolutely hated and it will not stay.
I did not initially love Consider Phlebas until I had read more of his Culture novels.
I'm probably going to cross off Contact, even though I loved it.
It was one of those hidden gem books that I absolutely adored.
Darwinia was pretty okay, pretty decent. Definitely went into left field at the end for me.
This is another transformative book that is so essential to science fiction and what an incredible writer she is. I don't know of anyone else who can put the reader in such an uncomfortable space and yet show you and make you feel everything that the character felt in that situation.
While I really did like Diaspora, I felt like there was a little bit of pretentiousness and inaccessibility to Diaspora that I don't think most people would enjoy.
The Doomsday Book was a really good story, alternate history with some black plague adventures. However, I'm not totally convinced that it was to the quality of Fire Upon the Deep.
Now, this is one that I love this author and I should have liked everything about the summary and the story, but for some reason I just didn't connect with it and I probably need to do a reread of it, but I didn't love this particular one.
Dragon's Egg, which was a really incredible story about a bunch of aliens who live on a star, very interesting.
Electric Forest blew me away. The ending of that story recontextualized everything that I read in that whole story and what sounded like a very superficial simple story became a thousand times better, and I was very impressed with it.
So, I loved Ender's Game. I thought it was a very fun, very fast-paced, very easy to get into, but fun and twisty, and it is definitely a fan favorite and for good reason.
I don't think I would give Eon this award because I felt like it was rather juvenile.
I absolutely adored Fools' War. I was very surprised, and it's a book that I keep coming back to over and over to recommend to people.
In 1998, we had Forever Peace by Joe Haldeman win, which is frankly embarrassing. This book embarrassing.
This is a very important book because it's the fourth book in his Foundation series, and it starts to connect two of his famous series. So, I kind of see why it won, and I did really enjoy it.
This book really impressed me. I really had a good time.
I HATE this series. I have explained this long and ad nauseam, and it's just not a series for me.
I also feel the same way about Heroes Die. Again, very fantasy.
Hyperion is probably my number one science fiction book of all time.
I Who Have Never Known Men, which isn't strictly science fiction, but boy is it something special.
I really did like Ice Henge. I thought it was a very interesting concept.
Again, what a fun book. However, not award-worthy, in my opinion.
Mockingbird kind of recycled a lot of Brave New World, but added in some little tiny pieces that I thought Philip K. Dick would have been really proud of.
And while I don't necessarily think it was a better book than Neuromancer, I do think it was a more enjoyable read, and it dealt with some really important topics.
However, was it an enjoyable book? For me, no, it wasn't.
I do have to say I really like Nor Crystal Tears. I really, really like what Alan Dean Foster was doing with that whole series of books, but does it deserve an award?
I really did think that On Basilisk Station was a great one. It's definitely a cult classic, but is it better than some of these other books? I think probably no.
Parable of the Sower was fantastic. It is definitely gaining in popularity for a reason.
The Parable of Talents was a phenomenal follow-up to Parable of the Sower.
The one standout for me is going to be Permutation City by Greg Egan, which is probably one of his most accessible works. So, I think Permutation City definitely should have won this year.
I do think that it had some really cool ideas, some really fun adventure. Is it his best work? Not necessarily, but is it better than Barrayar? Yes.
Remnant Population, which I absolutely loved, a very unique, important story.
I have to say no to Door into Ocean and no to Replay, although it was a fun book.
I'm probably going to say no to Santiago, even though I love it, and if you haven't read it, you should definitely read it.
I definitely would give the award to Snow Crash and Fire Upon the Deep. Both of these books are fantastic classics for reason, and I do put them on equal standing.
I thought this book was so much better than Ender's Game, and is definitely in one of my top echelons of all-time best science fiction.
I think that one was a fun thriller, but would it win a Woogo? Probably not.
Starfarers was a fun read, but was it an award-winning read? I'm going to say no.
This is definitely an uplift novel that was a very fun, but it wasn't anything particularly new or special for me.
I am not a huge fan of Stations of the Tide. Even though I'm sure it's great, it definitely went over my head, and I didn't love it.
I loved Steel Beach, but it's definitely a humor book, and it's definitely not for everyone.
I'm also going to go ahead and cross off Sundiver even though I liked it better than the second book. I seem to have liked it a lot more than a lot of other people, but I don't think it's qualifying for a Hugo this year.
So, that kind of leaves Many-Colored Land and Windhaven, both of which were fantastically fun stories, but I don't know that I loved them enough to give them a Hugo.
This book I have lots of controversial mixed opinions on because some of these ideas were so incredibly mind-blowing. However, the execution was just super opaque and confusing and definitely deals with a reread.
I do think I liked Hyperion better than A Fall of Hyperion, not that we're comparing necessarily this particular year.
And this is a book that I did like, although it is mostly about a space elevator, so quite a lot of hard sci-fi, not a whole lot of storyline.
We also have Gate to Women's Country, which was a very important feminist work, but was it better than Cyteen? In my opinion, no.
I did not love Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.
I probably would not give the postman, even though I loved that book, I would cross off both of those.
And while I thought Ringworld Engineers was fantastic, it was better than the first one in my opinion.
The Rise of Endymion, the end of the Hyperion Quartet, is and always will be one of the most mind-blowing reads of my sci-fi career.
Very unpopular opinion, I did not enjoy Shadow of the Torturer, and I don't think that alone, Shadow of the Torturer would qualify as an award. That series is very much its own solid unit or entity, and you have to read the whole thing to really get it.
It takes place on a world, there's a lot of sci-fi concepts, but it's very much written in the same way that fantasy is. I did enjoy it, but let's see what the other candidates are.
This was a really exceptional story and I'm really sad that it ended up getting so snubbed in the Hugos.
I wasn't too impressed with Terminal Experiment, even though I know it won the Nebula.
Now, I did like this book, but I found this book to have significantly lost the plot and the promises of the climax to that plot completely. While I found the universe fascinating, for an author to just drop the plot like that was really discombobulating for me.
I do love the Vorkosigan Saga, but I think it's a fun feel-good series and not necessarily super award-winning material.
Unless The Courtship of Princess Leia did something really special, which it did for Star Wars, but probably not for the Hugo, I would probably not give that one an award.
I also liked The Engines of God, but I didn't love it.
In terms of execution, enjoyability, and themes, I mean, Diamond Age definitely has the ideas and themes, but the execution's definitely The Killing Star. I'm going to go with The Killing Star.
I have to say I loved Madness Season. It was a very interesting kind of story, but it definitely is not necessarily award-winning for me.
We have Player of Games, which was a fantastic, short, interesting little look into the culture.
This Alien Shore was such a fun cozy read. It reminded me of the series of Firefly in a way. I really did enjoy it, but I don't think I would give it an award.
I do also have to say that I loved the first part of Time Like Infinity and didn't quite love the ending.
Titan was a very interesting one, but it's definitely science fantasy.
This one requires a British sense of humor and maybe a brick wall so you can slam your head into it over and over again. Oh, this was not a book for me.
Use of Weapons was both an intellectual hit as well as an emotional one. The structure, the writing, the plot, the storytelling, oh my gosh, unbeatable.
When Gravity Fails was a really important one, very interesting cyberpunk, but took place with Muslims ruling the world, which is very different and an intriguing way to frame the world.
So, that kind of leaves Many-Colored Land and Windhaven, both of which were fantastically fun stories, but I don't know that I loved them enough to give them a Hugo.













































































