Outlaw Bookseller 21.6K subscribers · Feb 2, 2025

Your Top 5 Most OVERRATED SCIENCE FICTION WRITERS- I respond to your comments #sciencefictionbooks

Reviews36

Mixed

it is a challenging book and it's got that wonderful circular structure which Alan Mo borrowed for Watchman with a beginning the end link up and you then get stuck in that Loop and read the book forever which would be just amazing

Loved

patent recognition is arguably set about 5 minutes in the future but it's not really SF but the beauty of it is it feels like SF and it shows you how science fiction and the Contemporary world are when in the same thing now

Loved

I really love Solaris I have to say I tend to like the parts which are in the book which are not in the films which people dislike the whole thing about the problem of knowledge with the Solaris library and hundred years of research and that I love that

Loved

just read caves of Steel and Naked Sun they're far better books far more entertaining far better written and their novels and you know the characters are just far more interesting the situations are far more interesting

Loved

just read caves of Steel and Naked Sun they're far better books far more entertaining far better written and their novels and you know the characters are just far more interesting the situations are far more interesting

Mixed

he introduces two of the characters and he brings in their for names and surnames but not together and this they split up in a way which is infuriating it get you struggling to pull the two together and that is kind of a cognitive dissonance thing which is common to SF but it seemed needless to me in that particular context

Mixed

I was a big fan of the seedling Stars his pantropy book and I reread that recently and I covered it in a video on the channel but a year ago because I think it's the source of things like children of time and very much when I read it wasn't as good as I remembered and it certainly was uneven