I understand it's a fixup novel, but it really doesn't come together as a cohesive plot, and I did not enjoy it. So, it's very low on my list. Do not like.
SciFi That Took the 60s by Storm || 1960s Hugo Winners Ranked
- Ranking · 11 books
The intricacies of politics and religion and how people behind the scenes are manipulating the power dynamics and people's religious beliefs into making something that is a really incredible story is something that's very special. And Frank Herbert really came up with something really awesome here.
I found that he had beautiful writing that seemed to distract from the fact that he did not seem to have a plot in large sections of this book. So, I did not enjoy the story. I would be more than happy to burn it and never read it again.
You guys, when I say that this book was one of the most predictive books I have ever read, he was right with so many different things in this story. This book really is something special.
I really enjoyed this book, and I love how he challenges the reader to have an opinion on different items and different philosophies and morals than any other author on this list.
This does not hold up the test of time and is laughably bad. It's not even interestingly controversial or something that makes me think. It doesn't bring up any really cool ideas.
This book was a nothing burger. The definition of nothing interesting happens in this story. Nothing.
This is the book that I felt like actually did have potential at the very beginning of the story and then it just evolved into X-rated softcore furry porn. I don't really understand why this book was allowed to be published.
So this one is my favorite of Heinland's novels so far. I think it's one of my favorites because I just fell in love with these characters.
This was an actual cohesive story. I understood what he was doing unlike Lord of Light. However, I just didn't feel anything great about it.
This one was an enjoyable little cozy read. While I do think that it feels a little bit older than a lot of these other books that were on the list, it was one that was a little bit more silent, a little bit more contemplative, and one that I enjoyed just a little bit more.










