I like the beginning part quite a lot the middle bit which is about two researchers living on a spaceship on its way to Jupiter was it with Hal the AI which is mostly what I remember from the movie and what I think it's most famously associated with in terms of the imagery that part was forgettable to me and the resolution of that conflict wasn't that exciting and then the book moves on to the best part of it which is the ending which is the confrontation within alien intelligence that is quite spectacular
Battle of the Hard Sci-Fi Classics [100 Book Challenge #35-40]
I've now read The Big Three from him this 2001 which is coming up next and childhood's end all three of them have excellent endings
before this I had really only read the foundation Trilogy the original Foundation Trilogy by Asimov and I love two of those books the first two I think are wonderful
I just found them again vanilla and they were all very cut and dry just we're gonna run through one of these laws of robotics through these specific parameters and any kind of like narrative flourish or character work it's incidental to just kind of teasing out how such and such variable would play out in such and such circumstance which didn't really make for that great of reading to me
his prose is bad it's often bad it's bad in this it wasn't bad in orphans in the sky
I'm two chapters in and you know like borderline want to weep for how beautiful it is I mean how potent that prose is
I think I gave this a 7 out of ten that feels about right to me certainly didn't dislike it but I don't I'm not infatuated with it
an uneven book I think that it is worth reading I certainly don't think that it's his best book I think Foundation trounces it but Asimov has flashes of greatness
this feels a lot like the cat who walked through walls which I tried to read and I found it like disgusting just in terms of how try hard the pros was
it's painfully long it is painfully slow the pros was Agony to me I really hated it was written in the voice of the Russian protagonist in a Russian voice so there are conjunctions missing in the construction of the sentences of most of the sentences









