Outlaw Bookseller 21.6K subscribers · Feb 9, 2025

The WORST of PHILIP K. DICK? Which books to avoid? #sciencefictionbooks

Reviews15

Mixed

When you get to the Lies, Inc. versions, there are additions of LSD trips and things like that, which are more Dickian in some ways, but actually the two things hang together quite poorly. But it's still a very interesting book to look at.

Mixed

A classic example of a broken-backed novel from Dick's sort of 60s period is The Crack in Space. And this now is entitled in the UK Cantata 140 because the original shorter version was called Cantata 140. And really this is quite a weak book, but a very interesting one nonetheless.

Disliked

One theory that I broadly agree with, which was put forward by Kim Stanley Robinson, is the idea that the appearance of evil aliens in a PKD novel is an indication of weak work in his oeuvre. So in which books do these evil aliens, which are part of ramshackle plots, pop up? Well, they come up notably in The Game Players of Titan.

Disliked

The result at the end of The Simulacra is a kitchen sink of a book that even by PKD standard of multi-conceptual construction simply fails and falls apart. There are too many plates spinning, too many loose ends which are not tied up and remain loose, and it's a rare example of mid-'60s PKD letting everything just get out of control as natural literary entropy takes its toll.