Willow Talks Books 77.8K subscribers · Nov 8, 2025

Dark academia is changing...

Reviews6

Loved

Now, RF Kuang has already made her stamp on the world of dark academia by writing what many, myself included, consider the greatest dark academia novel of all time, Babel.

Loved

In fact, the genre has become so wrote and so predictable that one of my favorite novels in the whole world, If we Were Villains by ML Rio, is often criticized by readers for being too similar to Donatart's The Secret History. And while I absolutely see their point, I do still prefer this book to that one.

Mixed

If you think back to The Secret History or If We Were Villains, those two books both have protagonists who are a group of students that get up to no good and do bad things. And they're very much books about the questions of morality and the fact that we are all made up of gray areas.