Outlaw Bookseller 21.6K subscribers · Feb 7, 2023

Another ROBERT SILVERBERG MASTERPIECE + January Science Fiction Reviews Wrap-Up #sf #sciencefiction

Reviews19

Mixed

it goes from one thing to another to another and this is the issue I have with Ian I often don't like where he takes me and I say it's probably my failing not here so I thought I got very frustrated

Loved

it's got an interesting opening and closing sequence with from a frame narrative and then the main part of the analysis is quite different it's got a Tower of Babel type thing going on but it's really fantastic

Loved

all the characters of fire they're all spiky and horrible I hated all of them but it was really enlivening because she thought gosh these people you know they file you know they're all terrible in their own way but you just loved it because they were such fully rounded human beings they were real people they leapt off the page and the idea is astonishing

Liked

I'm going to reread The Ballad of beta 2 as well because that's a good one that's about a Generation Starship being studied or that the work which has come out of a Generation Starship or the lack of Aesthetics being studied by student in the future

Mixed

on a reread I enjoyed it more it was interesting looking at the wider con sort of context of Delaney's work I'm all literally I've read since then most of which I read in the 80s and it's still though I didn't find it that exciting

Loved

I would put this on a par with possibly the man in the Maze which I think is my number five so I would say this is possibly number six but I absolutely loved it but it's certainly in my top six and I'm really glad I went back to it

Mixed

it is of interest if you like stalker I would give a region diary is a good writer I do have that bias against him so give it a try I enjoyed her exciting time but it's going to be handed on to a friend of mine I'm not going to read it again