Mike's Book Reviews 151K subscribers · Mar 8, 2026

Breaking Down Your Most Unhinged Hot Takes | 70 Responses & My Reaction

Reviews32

Liked

Traditional fantasy in that regard where you're getting to know this character. It takes a while to get established and then it'll take off and then it'll slow back down again and let you just kind of exist with his characters for a while.

Mixed

there's a big time jump in the middle of that book and all the characters that spent 300 pages getting you attached to weren't there anymore and you were doing something different and it kind of bummed me out and I said I was going to take a break and then I never went back to it but I should not have done that.

Disliked

the protagonist in the Poppy War unlikable to so much who I just wanted to like rip the pages out while I was reading. I knew that was very bad. So, I don't think it's the worst book in the last 50 years, but I definitely don't think it was good.

Liked

Wizard and Glass, I get why people don't like it. me. I always wanted to know more about Roland's backstory, but I do understand that, hey, we did just take an entire brick of a book in midstory and give you a backstory.

Disliked

I think in that book there are characters I could give a damn about or don't even know they're there and the show really gave them some agency and did a much better job.