I do really like what she's trying to do with the ending. I think there's a lot of execution flaws for me and my tastes and my character connection or lack thereof with her characters and the pacing of the story in the middle. But it's not a bad book.
Ranking 10 Award Winning Books || Reacting to 2022 SFF Release Award Winners
She's just dumb, and infuriating and frustrating. And so that's, that's why I don't think it's not I don't think it's badly crafted or anything like that. But it was very plot driven.
But like in terms of the preachiness of like othering people in academia and stuff like that, like I preferred that very didn't weigh more, even though they're both so on the nose. It's aggressive.
I reread the first book, and I loved it. I loved it the first time I loved it the second time, the first book is so good.
And there's too much nothing going on in this many pages. Am I going to read the third book? Yes, I need to know how it ends. But yeah, this was a big disappointment for me, especially because I reread the first book, and I loved it.
If anything, it's really knowing the tropes and playing with them so efficiently and effectively that it creates such a tight well crafted story.
It just pretty much left my brain the minute I finished reading. That's why it's just fine for me. It didn't do anything too special for me compared to other things that I had read.
Like as a reader, like her character work has not gotten better for me since I've read the poppy war.
It's a challenging, dense read. But it is a fantastic standalone that truly understands epic fantasy, while being very true to its roots. It's Filipino, you know, influences and everything like that I loved this book.








