Literature Science Alliance 10.6K subscribers · Jul 16, 2024

Popular Books that I don't Like || Unpopular Opinions

Reviews22

Mixed

I just don't think the last book is that good, and maybe I really just, like, can't relate to the fandom because I didn't get to reread these while I was growing up. I just read them all once all the way through.

Disliked

And as soon as the plot doesn't have a place for them, she forgets to write about them for pages, and then finds a way to remove them, like it's just very like the lack of ensemble cast character work is bad for me, and that has continued to happen to me and some of her other works, like Babel and stuff like that.

Liked

Reading it, I felt no catharsis. I guess maybe, ifit was cathartic for the author, great, if it maybe made people more empathetic to people who grew up in these situations, awesome, but in general, it felt relentless and demon Copperhead, although it also had moments that made me want to stop the book and stop reading it, let the character also live a life that was multicolored, like a life that is sad and full of trauma is not devoid of hope.

Loved

I really like the first foundation book. I just want to be on the record saying I gave that five stars. I love the first foundation book, and maybe I need to reread it, knowing the project and how it shifts so dramatically.

Mixed

It like, there are, again, moments of brilliance in Gideon the night that I enjoyed, but its pacing was really wonky, and I legit, it's 10:30am in the morning. I'm a morning person. I'm finishing the end of Gideon the ninth.

Mixed

Because I read the first three, and I was like, okay, but I read grave peril at like, a time in my life where, like, I was emotionally distraught, and that's an emotionally distressing book in the series. And I was like, Eh, maybe I'm done.

Disliked

And then there were, like, big negative things that happened that I don't feel like the book interrogated, and I was like, am I supposed to be okay, that we just did a little genocide? Like, am I and I don't know, because I was just waiting for the book to also agree with me that was bad, and it never really did.

Disliked

But the big difference for me is that in sugibane, we were never allowed to see moments of light, except when the author wanted to then drag the rug from under us. And, like, I'm not saying that's an inaccurate portrayal of what happened to sugibane or the author, but it was relentless, and it caused me to have depression and anxiety attacks as someone who had a parent who had drug problems, and it just didn't feel kind.

Mixed

So the combination of like, the world wasn't really opening up to me, like it does other readers, and the fact that, like, it wasn't as episodic as I wanted it to be, and we're still dealing with sad stuff, I was just like, it's fine.

Disliked

So I was just really bummed by the execution of this third book. It was just missing a lot of the depth and magic I felt from the first two so Yeah, and like, it just started to show me, like, sometimes the things she wants to work on don't work for me.

Disliked

I just don't get it, because everyone's just always about these two leads, and then they're like, well, it's the wicked king where it gets good. Don't agree with that there either it's just boring.