lexi aka newlynova 350K subscribers · Nov 8, 2025

katabasis, r.f. kuang, and modern dark academia (a spoiler-free vlog & review)

Reviews6

Loved

I personally still think that Babel is her best work and the advantage of reading Babel first is that I also think that book is the closest in tone and stylistically to what you would get with this.

Liked

It's still getting four stars from me. And I hope that this entire discussion helps illuminate to you why I do think, yeah, it's my least favorite so far in RF Kuang's catalog, but even a kind of mid RF Kuang book is still going to be one of the best things I've read this month.

Loved

You're telling me that my darling RF Kuang is writing an academic rivals to lovers story that's also a journey through the underworld that's also pitched in the same vein as Pyreazy, another one of my favorite fantasy books.

Mixed

I didn't even love The Secret History when I read it. It was a pretty mixed bag for me. But the theming overall was so bang-on that it like proliferated the world with evidence of its own main idea that people just kept continuously misunderstanding somehow after they read that book.

Loved

I remember back when Yellowface came out and I read it, I immediately went on to have a three-hour discussion about the book with one of my friends who had not read the book, but was like just as interested in talking about it as I was and talking about all of the different philosophical ideas and debates that book kind of raises.