lexi aka newlynova 350K subscribers · Nov 8, 2023

tier ranking every book i've ever rated five stars ⭐️

  • Ranking · 54 books

Reviews51

Loved

for now it is an easy six-star perfect book no notes I thought it was fantastic and if the premise sounds like anything that is even kind of compelling to you I think that you're really going to enjoy it

Liked

I think that it's pretty likely that I overrated this book a little bit honestly because of how bonkers the situation is it's five star drama it's t but as a book I think that it's probably more of a 4.5 or a four based on how much I remember enjoying the actual reading experience

Loved

it's such a hard breaking story like it has essentially every trigger warning in it all of them just Sauced in there but it's just told with so much light and compassion like I've never seen an author do it quite like that before

Loved

in this book the way that she captures this complicated relationship that she has with her love for her family that is still there despite all of the bad things that have happened to her is just H it breaks your spirit while also simultaneously healing you and like ascending you to a different place

Loved

I was so invested in Don's story that I canel my plans which like lowkey I'm always looking for an excuse to cancel my plans but this book also just gave me no choice like it was twisty it was turny it was really good it had me wired up until I finished it

Liked

I loved the main couple I loved the dynamic that they had throughout the book but I recall this book having the nonsense that sometimes romance novels have where it's just 50 to 70 pages of the characters thriving in agony with the same thought patterns every single time around why they can't have the other person

Liked

I really related to some of the personality conflicts that both of the characters were kind of facing within themselves but looking back even then there were things in the book that I thought were kind of overwhelming and the central Crux of the book felt like it relied a little bit too much on the miscommunication Trope

Liked

the book that I always recommend when people ask me for similar things is pure Andy but even that did not hit the same like you'll notice that is not on this list for me despite the fact that it is a book that I enjoy

Mixed

looking back there are things that are just kind of weird in this book lowkey The love interest is kind of creepy and possessive which I Remember Loving at the time and the endless desire to make the main character like as Quirky as it was possible for a tiny little woman to be it's a little cringe looking back

Loved

I guarantee you if I were to read this book again I would give it five stars I would be emotional about the fact that I read this book at such a low point in my life and be very thankful that I did and that it did work for me

Mixed

I don't know what I would give this book if I were to read it again but my thoughts on the author have like complicated my entire relationship with her catalog so much that in my head now it's almost a one-star book which can't be true because I liked it

Liked

I actually love this book I would give it a 4.5 but I read or heard a take somewhere in the past 6 months nobody knows when but it's in my brain now that I really agreee with which is that I think this book could have been shorter