* e m m i e * 467K subscribers · Nov 8, 2022

every book I read in June | classics, making progress on series & sci-fi

Reviews22

Liked

A lot of this first book is also a meditation on writing novels. How do you go about writing? And at times it's extremely sloppy but because he's kind of set himself up as taking on the guise of a narrator in here who is writing his first novel or writing something it's kind of excusable in that way which is something cool to explore as well but yeah, overall I gave both of these three and a half stars and this just made me want to read all the Murakami in my life so I'm really happy I picked these up.

Liked

I did end up liking Pinball a lot more, but these two are connected and I believe there are four in total Murakami works that follow the unnamed narrator of these two novels as well as his friend, who is just this guy known as the Rat.

Disliked

I thought this was going to be such a cute wholesome kind of similar food manga because I was really liking Kitchen Princess and I kind of wanted something more like that but this was entirely ridiculous. It was not heartwarming to me and I was just like I am uncomfortable I don't want to be here.

Mixed

Some of his sentences hit me so hard, and a lot of his sentiments I really do I'm just in love with, but as well sometimes he's just so annoying, like so annoying, so full of himself, so It's just too nebulous. It's too nebulous for me.

Liked

The thing that stopped me from giving it any more than four stars, and like it was kind of just a four-star for me, is that I wanted a lot more time with our characters because this is a relatively short book, and there are a lot of people in here who have incredibly deep, complicated, meaningful relationships. I wanted more of that.

Disliked

The reason that I DNF this was because I was finding the writing so inconsistent, specifically with Molly. And I've seen other people talk about this, too, when I went on Goodreads.

Loved

Turn of the Screw is one of my favorite books and so this for me was just Henry James 180, like he can really do anything, I think, which is cool, but as a story, like I would definitely not recommend this unless you have to analyze it.