Books and Things 39K subscribers · Aug 31, 2024

Victober 2024 | Announcement and Recommendations

Reviews32

Mixed

remember the first time I was listening to the study in Scarlet on audio book and we got to halfway through the book and suddenly we moved away from Watson and Sherlock holes to a completely new character and a completely new setting and I was like have has this audio book Gone Wrong is this a new book but no it is just the study in Scarlet

Liked

those Victorian kind of fantasy novels that pretend that they are travel writing or that sort of like have a conceit of being travel writing throughout them as part of their form and structure such as araon by Samuel Butler from 1872 all about a traveler who discovers this other world

Loved

I thought man and wife was so fantastic such a compelling dramatic pacy novel slightly slow start but like once you get past a slightly slow start it's fantastic and some of the characterization in that is like will he Collins at his best

Liked

this is a collection of short stories with a frame narrative the idea being that the kind of frame narrator is unwell so she's kind of like bound to her sofa she can't really move around very much and people come and tell her stories and a lot of the rest of the book is those stories

Liked

another book with a frame narrative is the house by the churchard by J Sheridan lefanu a work of historical Victorian fiction from 1864 set in the 18th century although we have a bit of a frame narrative where someone in chapter 1 is present when someone's body is dug up in a churchyard and this person skull has some unusual injuries to it and then we go back in time to the 18th century to find out what happened to this person

Loved

I love the way the Moonstone plays with perspective and it's something that works really well for this novel's premise because this book is all about a stolen diamond and we learn about this diamond and what has happened to it through lots and lots of different perspectives

Disliked

I will be honest I don't love the term the screw but also it is very much a frame narrative and it felt like weird not to mention it because I know that Henry James is for a lot of people even if he just isn't really for me