Books and Things 39K subscribers · Dec 23, 2025

November Reading Wrap Up

Reviews14

Loved

It was interesting to read though because it is very historically interesting and also I kept thinking about the character of Odia slope in B the towers by Anthony Trrollop who's Francis Trrollop's son and Odias slope is a fantastic character and I feel like Obadia slope was Anthony Trrollop reading his mother's book the vicar of rectail and being like I don't believe that man but I could write a version of him that would be real and would be believable and is human and I think that's what Overdai slope is.

Loved

I was expecting it to sort of rival in my mind far from the Madden Crowd, Jude the Obscure, and The Woodlanders, which are my three favorite Hardies, and I'm not sure it does.

Mixed

There are some bits of Shirley that I absolutely love. I think there are some truly incredible scenes, some really interesting moments. But it is quite long and there are so many bits of it that I just kind of don't think you need.

Liked

I think the narrative is fascinating and the story is great and really powerful and really moving and there's some fantastic bits. and I think it's a really clever, interesting novel, but it just didn't quite hit me as hard as I was expecting.

Mixed

And I do think as I think in Vallet as well, I think Charlotte Bronte writes incredibly about depression and loneliness and sort of like a complete despair for the future. That's something that Caroline in Shirley and Lucy Snow in Vallet both experience and I think Charlotte Bronte captures it fantastically.