Loved itI think my favorite is probably book eight magic shifts and that's an interesting favorite I feel like because it actually shifts the series a little bit it's a bit of a reset because I believe at 1.7 was supposed to be the last book but the reason that I really loved it is that it kind of goes back to like early Kate days in terms of feeling more like a procedural but with all of the characters that you've built up all of this love and feelings for so it's the best of both worlds