Thoughts on Tomes 63.4K subscribers · Apr 15, 2026

recent reads: lake monsters, biopunk detectives, re-reads of old favorites, and bad YA dystopians

Reviews18

A Study in DrowningAva Reid
Loved it

besides A Study in Drowning, which I never read the sequel to because I just consider that a standalone, I don't think Ava Reed works well for me with YA.

AtmosphereTaylor Jenkins Reid
Loved it

This is getting back up there again. So, this was a four star. I liked it, but I wasn't like totally pulled in, but overall still really enjoyed it.

Becoming KinPatty Krawec
Mixed

this was fine. I listened to this on audio. I think if I hadn't read other books by Indigenous authors that I think are kind of like so foundational, this would have hit more.

it got a little bit annoying towards the end of the book, but the beginning I quite enjoyed. And I ultimately like did enjoy their relationship when they weren't being dum-dums. So, three out of five stars.

this was a two-star for me because there were moments that were good in this. but overall, I was like, this world-building is so weak, this like characters, how these two characters are trusting each other, so weak.

FathomfolkEliza Chan
Not a fan

I got like a little over a hundred pages in and like kind of nothing was happening. ... I just didn't really want to pick it up.

Green TeethMolly O'Neill
Loved it

I really loved this and I'm excited for the future of Maggie O'Neal stuff. ... I gave this a 4.5 out of 5 because the end was like a little rushy.

I found this book really fascinating. I gave this four stars because there were parts of it towards the end that were more geared towards people who were using alcohol more as a coping mechanism.

Wind WitchSusan Dennard
Loved it

this was just as good on reread, if not better. Like, every time I reread this book in particular in the series, I enjoy it more.