However, I'm putting it in a review wrap-up video, which you notice is often where I kind of tuck away books that I have less to say about or less to love about because of the fact that the book completely fell apart later into the story where it just got really messy. It was trying to do too many things.
New Year, New SFF Reviews!
I think if you take away that element, I would say in my opinion that the book is a little bit weaker. It doesn't stand on its own in the way that it needs that angle in order for this book to be charming. So, it is a little bit of a criticism in the way that I like books to be multifaceted and not have one particular element or trope kind of holding up the whole worth of the story.
And having read a lot of hard science fiction that clearly understands the ins and outs of some of the technical aspects of space travel, despite my best efforts, I found myself comparing this book to other again hard science fiction authors that have tackled similar topics and this one just really pald in comparison. So I did find the characters, the writing, all of that to be quite average.
I like this one on a surface level. Honestly, it didn't really excite me or engross me or enthral me. I didn't find it objectively bad.
I really like the first one. I'll be honest, I didn't love the second one as much. I think it might be a little bit due to the fact that I read them quite spread out and a lot of my drive and excitement from the first book has simmerred and so it is a series that I think would work better if you were to binge them back to back.
There were times that it did lean into some tropes that I found a little bit tiring and some of the writing again got a bit cliche, but overall I end up being pretty happy with it. I liked how the ending went, which is not something I expected to say and overall, yeah, really happy I read this one.
I really like the first one. I'll be honest, I didn't love the second one as much.
Again, I thought that the premise was interesting. The execution was well done. The characters were reasonably well-developed for a kind of story where again more classic science fiction isn't necessarily looking to have a literary character dissection within the story.







