But anyway, all that being said, despite all my criticisms, I actually had a really good time with this one. It was very enjoyable to get back into the world.
WORTH THE HYPE? || New 2025 SFF Reviews
And largely, again, the Scottish clan callbacks really were what pulled me through. So, a simple story, an easy one, but an enjoyable one if you're looking for that.
So, it's a really fun book that really explores the idea of what happens if someone gets a second chance at youth and how they use it and quite frankly, they hop around like bunnies before going off to war. And so the book is a really good balance between having some good moments in terms of really examining military life and war and those deeper conversations that normally are put into heavier books but then also cross balancing it with having some lighter topics at the same time.
Picked up this one with very little expectation and loved it. So, this is a story that is set in a world where there's alchemy and it can be used to transform the world.
But the first book very much and it leads into this one ties around a world that is very much unstable due to natural events. And so that is very much a piece of the world building that ties into all the books. I found that to be very interesting.
But I ended up really enjoying this one. I thought it was a satisfying ending. again, not maybe the best book of the year, but very much a solid ending to a solid series.
I did enjoy or appreciate parts of it. It's just not a personal favorite of mine, but again, I definitely has an audience.
The characters were good. I think that the author is good at writing like funny characters and having characters do funny, quirky things, but aren't necessarily again the most fleshed out characters.







