TheShadesofOrange 41.9K subscribers · Sep 23, 2025

MORE New Horror Reviews for the Halloween Season

Reviews9

Liked

So, again, it feels very cozy and comforting to an adult reader like myself, I enjoyed it. Go in with the right expectations. If you're expecting this to be the best middle-rade book you've ever read, I don't think it's to that extent.

Mixed

And I have no real criticisms of this one other than it not necessarily being to my taste. I will note that again, if you're looking for a full-fledged horror novel, you won't necessarily get there. Instead, you kind of just get that dark, beautiful, creepy aspects to it.

Mixed

The story is very functional, the writing is fine, but I want to have a story like this with really lush writing. I felt like this one didn't hit the potential that it could have, you know, if it had something more in the style of the historian or other books that really you can sink your teeth into.

Disliked

But if I'm honest, as you can probably guess, I just couldn't get into this one, so I did put it aside. But again, in terms of a premise and setup, I love a story of a character, especially a female character, latching on to some evil entity in order to protect herself.