TheShadesofOrange 41.9K subscribers · Apr 2, 2026

Read This Novel if You Love the Witcher | SFF Reviews

Reviews6

Loved

One that completely surprised me and there just was a darkness, a uniqueness, a freshness to that first book that really grabbed my attention and it ended up, I believe, being one of my favorites of the year. Very much a surprise and in my mind a hidden gem and I do still stand by my recommendation for that one.

Mixed

I'm purposely leaving it a little bit vague, but what I want to say is that I like this one, but in my mind, it felt like a very familiar, safe, somewhat tropy or very tropy fantasy story that felt very expected, very again familiar, and that's not necessarily a bad thing, but unfortunately, it felt very opposite to the freshness, the uniqueness that I found in The Blade Priest that made me love it so much.

Disliked

Unfortunately, in my mind, and again, this is my opinion, which I am a little bit cautious to be too strong in giving in this video, but I felt like the message in the story was muddled and I felt like the author could have gone a bit more on the nose, a bit more straightforward, and told a story that in my mind would have had more of an impact and again, more of a lasting impression on me. So, it's a book where the execution didn't work for me.