However, as a whole, I found the story to be quite lackluster. Quite frankly, I just found it to be very average in terms of the writing, the plot, everything felt very familiar and tropey and not particularly interesting or elevated.
Panic Reading 2025 Releases | SFF Reviews
This second book is solid, but in my mind, it lacks a little bit of the teeth. Maybe it's just a little bit less fresh or just suffers from middlebook syndrome cuz I think there's going to be a third book.
It was definitely an enjoyable read. I flew through it and generally enjoyed the mystery and who was behind it all.
And the world building, the larger technical aspects to the surrounding world and ships and all of that is very well done. You can tell that Elizabeth Bear has a love for the genre which is woven into the story while at the same time being very character focused, very plotheavy, and so it does move at a good pace.
I don't think it's the most memorable science fiction book I've read, but again, I recognize that not everyone is looking for that really dense, hard science fiction angle, and this one feels a little lighter, a little bit more character focus with a familiar and kind of fun with some twists and turns to the plot. So, again, an enjoyable read, but definitely temper your expectations accordingly.
It had some beautiful imagery. It had some nice writing at times, but this book wasn't very punchy, and if you know my tastes in books, usually I'm looking for something that is going to go there and go farther and so forth, and that's just not what this book is.




