And if you follow my channel, you might know that the first book in this series, Age of Ash, made my favorite backlist titles for fantasy.
More 2023 Sci FI & Fantasy Books | SFF Book Reviews
So I like this one, but I will admit it may not make my favorites of the year. I don't think it left as strong as impression on me as the first book. I still really like the author's writing.
And in my mind, I thought that this one actually worked perhaps a little bit better for me because I felt like there was a little bit more action and set up because again, it was still during their warrior days. So, I actually almost prefer this one, which I think is an unlikely or unpopular opinion.
It's a case where I enjoyed again the voice of Murderbot, but for me, this is one of the most compelling plots in the whole series, because when somebody gets murdered, I enjoy that puzzle. This is a lot of fun, and this is definitely one of my favorites, but again, you start back at the beginning if you haven't yet.
The characters were well-drawn, diverse in a very natural way, just complex, morally gray, and you could easily understand or follow their motivations, but they were never, again like one-sided or stereotypes. There was some great neurodiversity and other different elements within the story. And I love the characters.
I ripped through the second book incredibly fast. And so, recommend if you're looking for more underhyped fantasy, one that I don't see talked about online, at least in my circles, this is one I'd recommend. I had a great time reading it, and I definitely hope there's another book coming because I definitely want more.
The first book is Guild of Tokens. And it's one I've recommended before.
I found it to be cute and quaint and cozy and a good palate cleanser between a lot of the dark and messed-up stories I tend to prefer. So, I thought that one was cute, and I have very similar feelings about this one.
I've read one book by this author before, The Misfit Soldiers, which was a fun, rompy military science fiction story. And it was fun, but I don't think it was trying to be anything to the extent of this one.
This, of course, is the full-length novel, and I got to say that I do think Murderbot works best in the short form, just because again, it's so episodic that I think it works good in those little snapshots, but given the fact that this is a novel, I thought the author did a good job of creating a plot that did feel a little bit more big, a little bit more epic, and I was generally compelled by it, but I don't know if this book needed to be a novel, but I still enjoyed my time with it.
This most recent book, I will admit, it was good, but not my favorite in the series, probably one of my least favorites. I just didn't find the plot that compelling, and really what I enjoyed most about this one was just spending time with the character of Murderbot, which is what I say pretty much about every book in the series.
But this is one that I had a really good time reading it in terms of it was easy to fly through. It was accessible and an intriguing story and moved along very well. But again, it's one of those stories where I had a good time reading it, but it didn't necessarily leave me with the most lasting impression.
Overall, I enjoyed this one, but I will admit there's something quite missing from it where it wasn't quite the memorable read I wanted it to be. A very enjoyable experience. I actually still gave it four stars, but even as I record this here, I read the book maybe about two weeks ago and I don't have the strongest impression of it compared to other books that I read years ago that stick with me a lot stronger.












