I really do love me some regresssocieties and this book I think is criminally underrated but it just doesn't compare in terms of memorability and pushing the genre forward like my top five of this decade do so I still highly recommend it
1970's Hugo Winning Science Fiction Books (My Ranking)
- Ranking · 10 books
this is one of those books that took me a little while to get into and I even had to sit around and think about it afterward to make sure that this is a book that I actually liked Robinette is a character that is a very unlikable however he's a little bit too relatable for my comfort and that's one of the reasons why I decided I liked this book
I got to say this book holds up even reading it in this decade I really enjoyed the story although I do think some people find it a little bit slower paced I loved the methodical approach that I found to be hyperrealistic
while I was interested in the world and the ring and what was on it and how it got there I felt like the story was a little bit more character-driven than I wanted it to be and kind of did not explore the ring as much as I wanted I also found there to be a lot of overt sexism and racism and even some mention of eugenics here that I don't feel like stood the test of time
this book was an incredible read in terms of comparing and contrasting capitalism with what Socialism or Anarchy or communism could really be there's a lot of elements of all of those in both of the cultures and I really liked comparing and contrasting and seeing what they would really look like in Ursula's Vision but that said I didn't like the character Chev and I also didn't like the story
you guys I could not get over this book when I first read it because oh my gosh how did I wait this long to read it I found there to be so many little nitpicky gold nuggets in this story that had so much to talk about
this was such an incredible alien species that Isaac asov invented for somebody who was one of the big three fathers of sci-fi or whatever he's known as I think this book is criminally underrated I found his characterization to be very good in this story
I find it very sterile and emotionless for something that is supposed to be a love story and a and a connection over time and culture I just didn't find I related to either character very well
this book has my respect because it does not stray from jumping on and attacking those big questions like is this the afterlife I really enjoyed some of the topics that he's questioning and I really felt like this was one of those really deep thinking thoughtful sci-fi books that did deserve to win the Hugo award but I felt like there was very little to no resolution in the first book
I thought this book was one that was very easy to read in this decade it really stood the test of time and it really asked a lot of questions about individualism and whether that's a positive or A negative thing in our culture and I think that is a question that holds up today so I really enjoyed the story I really enjoyed it









