SciFiScavenger 14.1K subscribers · Feb 4, 2026

Three 9/10 sci-fi reads! But which will be my book of the month?

Reviews20

Loved

In a bit of an echo from the Dervish House, I enjoyed the clash of modernity and traditional in this book. I thought that Ryman did a really nice job painting life in the village and the villagers are not portrayed as stupid nor are they ignorant but they you know what they know and it's clear that they need some help.

Mixed

The rapid changes in perspective were jarring and the flow disjointed, and I actually came fairly close to a grumpy DNF at one point, but there was something about it that kept me coming back. But overall, I think it's another book that I admired more than I enjoyed and but I do think that it probably would reward a reread.

Mixed

I found Ice ambiguous throughout and not a little frustrating with it. I was never sure what was real or not or if anything described is actually happening and I suspect that's what Caven was aiming for.

Disliked

I got about a third of the way through it and decided it wasn't for me is Options by Robert Shekeley. And I the summary is I just found his writing style a bit grating. and I didn't appreciate the constant wise cracking.

Liked

I thought that the western setting was a bit of a pastiche. However, I thought that Mr. Kerry does layer on more and more background which adds some complexity and some nuance to the piece and actually by the end I was very vested in the story.

Liked

I also though enjoyed the speculative elements, the sense of wonder and the plausibility of the long range planning involved, albeit from a perhaps a highly implausible starting premise. And I felt that actually Robert Charles Wilson does a pretty good job of balancing those two elements.

Liked

I really like the way that McDonald blends the futuristic with the traditional, the non-tech and the robotics, the religious and the cultural, the shiny city offices, and the old wooden dervish house. Istanbul's painted as a teeming, vibrant city populated with striving and hopeful individuals.

Loved

I really enjoyed the essence and perhaps my greatest compliment is that the essence reminded me of the glamour by Christopher Priest, a book that I happened to read quite recently and very much enjoyed towards the end of last year.

Liked

I really enjoyed the essence and perhaps my greatest compliment is that the essence reminded me of the glamour by Christopher Priest, a book that I happened to read quite recently and very much enjoyed towards the end of last year.

Liked

Brown does a really nice job with both threads, I thought, taking a slightly different approach with each one. And while you begin to anticipate what the nature of the link might be between the two langans, when the reveal does come, it's done with some pache and actually is rather touching.