It's going to be a thumbs up because it was solid for what it was. I think my problem is just that it's only it's less than 200 pages, so it can only do so much, but it does do some interesting things with the plot and where it goes.
Tier Ranking Every Book I've Read So Far in 2025 (Part 2)
And yeah, I like this one. Like this one felt the most like a typical romance book than like some of her other ones. but it's really fun.
so yeah, it's a good book. it's definitely going in the thumbs up. It's probably like my third favorite out of the three that I've read from the author, but it's still like very atmospheric.
So yeah, while Bluebird is like a star or fire for me, this one is just like a thumbs up.
so like there was a lot of this book where I was just like yeah I've heard this before. I've read this before, but this is like a good collection about it and like hopefully, you know, strides are made in terms of like tuberculosis and cures and things like that.
So yeah, while Bluebird is like a star or fire for me, this one is just like a thumbs up. It's fine. I don't think it needed to exist.
This book had so much potential and I it just lost me. I am gonna put this in the shrug emoji tier list. because it's one of those books where I'm just like, it started off so strong and there were so many beautiful like passages and things like that and then it kind of just like goes off on tangents that didn't really feel relevant to the overall theme of the book and things like that.
You know, the book of the year or one of yeah, I absolutely love this. like this is a star rate like rating for me. I thoroughly enjoyed reading a book from He-Mich's perspective.
I read The Age of Miracles whenever it first came out and I love that book and so I was very excited to see a new book out by Karen Thompson Walker.
but otherwise, I love this book. I love reading about like my parents' home state in India and like just so much of the stuff that's referenced in this book like I know it so well like it's a part of my DNA. so it was just like a really wonderful book in that sense but also like I just think Abraham Fergus is a fantastic writer and this is just a really well done book and totally deserves all the praise that it's been getting.
I thought it was fine. like this would probably be a threest star book. Like I'll I'll give it a thumbs up as well.
but it did not work for me at all. Like this is the book where I'm like, "Yeah, I'm putting this one in the trash can."
it's going to get a thumbs up for me. Like I know a lot of people love this book. The main reason why this is not for me is cuz this is basically like a fairy tale and I'm just not a fairy tale person.
this is an author where I had read her previous books, The Snowchild and To the Ends of the Earth or something along those lines. I forgot what the book name of her second book is. but I really enjoyed these those books.
There were like parts of it I really enjoyed and the writing was so well done. but there are other parts of it that I didn't really enjoy.
It was fun. it's a little bit predictable. but it was enjoyable and honestly I'm going to put it in like I'm debating between thumbs up and star, but like honestly it's kind of going in star for me.
Like I remember enjoying this book and like I gave it like a 3.75 rating, but like I have to put it in the shrugo tier. It like it typically probably would have gotten a thumbs up, but I think it's going to be a shrug because I genuinely don't remember this book very strongly.
this is an author where I had read her previous books, The Snowchild and To the Ends of the Earth or something along those lines. I forgot what the book name of her second book is. but I really enjoyed these those books.
like it's not a bad book by any means. It's so like light and fluffy and predictable and like it's it's good. It's okay.
and yeah, it's just like a really like beautiful meditation on like life and growing up and grief and family and all of these other things that I just like really enjoy. And it went a lot of places that I wasn't really expecting.



















