I mean, I struggle to find anything I don't love about this book. And listening to it via audio just brought back all the fond memories of this because this was my second or third book by Kay and in many ways is what cemented my love for this author and I just I just loved the listening experience.
January '26 Book Reviews | SFF and More!
So this is really just a great work of military fantasy and I thought it was superbly done. The book was great. Love the ending.
Now that said, I thought some of the secondary story lines were a bit superfluous. I felt that they really didn't add as much to the story as much as they were in the book.
Didn't love it. One second after I thought it was just okay.
So although I can still say I like this book. I think I gave it three and a half stars, maybe three stars.
But overall I really love the world building. Lynch's writing is self assured and it's it's very rich and it's it's quite beautiful at times. And for me the greatness is just the depiction of this friendship between these two characters.
The book itself is good. I wouldn't call this a great start to a book series, but it did its job because I do want to continue to see where this story is going because of the initial premise, because of the parallels to Vagner's ring cycle, as well as just I've heard some great praise that at the very end of this book, a lot of like the brutal things that happen in this first book pay off at the end of the series.
I think the one thing, if there's one thing that I think didn't work in this book, the first book had a bunch of flashbacks and there were flashbacks flashing back to Lock and John kind of formative years and it kind of informed their characters and how they got together and it was really effective in that story.
But as it is, this was just okay.
And this book is primarily about grief because Harry's seen so much of his world destroyed. He's seen deaths to people that are close to him, some of the closest people to him. And he is he's grieving.
But I think this is very good because it's so short and concise, but it is really very focused.










