It is unbelievable. It's fantastic. One of the best works of crime noir I've read in several years.
May '26 Book Reviews | Some Potential Books of the Year!
The characterization was strong, but again, the plotting and pacing was a masterclass. It was really impressive that at no point did I feel like, wow, this is this is long, or man, can we speed up?
As a whole, it's it's a bit uneven as any collection like this would be. You know, some of these dispatches are super short and not very memorable. Some of them work really well.
The story itself was good. I think the execution was better than the actual story, which made it enjoyable for me.
I really loved especially the Bane of the Black Sword and Stormbringer, the last two and the second onus. Fantastic storytelling.
I really loved especially the Bane of the Black Sword and Stormbringer, the last two and the second onus. Fantastic storytelling.
But then the end of the book was super strong, like one of the strongest endings I think that he's written in his novels. So, I was back on board like, okay, it meandered in the middle, but solid ending.
I didn't feel the execution was super high, but I thought the narrative voice is strong, the character is strong, the writing's far better than just being competent. So, I'll definitely be reading more of these Matthew Scutter books, probably some with my eyes, some via audio book, but I did enjoy Sins of the Fathers by Lawrence Block.
And I found nothing personally from a plot, character, setting, or thematic standpoint that I found compelling. Maybe a little bit with character, just a little bit. But this was a huge disappointment for me.
The other thing that was done really well here is the plotting and the pacing of this book was done very well in particular one aspect. So there are there are a lot of times I've [snorts] read in the last few years a book where you're getting a story about a character and then when the author does a flashback and tells you something about the character's past when it's not done well it feels like the story has stopped so that the author can tell you this. But Windslow manages to weave that into the narrative here where it feels like it's at the right time.
U the way that he was able to wrap up this series was magnificent. impressive, extremely impressive what he was able to do.
I have read another work of his that's non-fiction that says travels with Charlie which is fantastic. That one is stronger than this one.











