And to be honest, I was kind of bored through a lot of this. I was waiting for something interesting to happen and overall this book was a bit of a letdown until the last 120 to 150 pages where oh, this story actually went somewhere and we got some characters thrown together that weren't likely to be predicted to be thrown together and having to cooperate and it was really interesting and the ending, except for the last chapter, was phenomenal.
March '26 Book Reviews | 10 Books | SFF & More
This was a surprise because this is probably a top five Star Wars novel that I've read. I think I've read 25 novels, I compiled a list a while back, and this is a top five for me.
And this was a great one. I found myself kind of emotional at the end, and it's typical Gemmell, consistent from beginning to end, pacing, plotting, story payoff at the end is there, just another great installment by Gemmell.
It was a really impactful text and I'm I really enjoyed reading it, although enjoy is probably not the best term. But I thought it was a great read.
I think Honor to Enemy, the one that the first book that he wrote with William Forstchen, is the best of the three, but I do love this world.
And unfortunately, this the story itself progressed through a great series of plot conveniences and that was disappointing because it was just one thing after another that oh, this just happened to happen, so now we're here and oh, and then this thing happened to happen, so that has to move us here.
I didn't feel the writing was as seamless in this one, but I enjoyed this one. If you're into that kind of story, it doesn't it's not a big story. It's a very self-contained story, but I enjoyed my time.
My only kind of big thing I didn't like about Sea of Rust was that the robots, they all kind of felt human. So, that aside, I really enjoyed it. I thought it was a good story.
And it's typical Connelly and the plotting is just perfect. But again, I loved kind of this rough around the edges writing style that's not as polished as later, and it worked really well for this first book.
It was one of those engrossing stories that you just get hooked into it early on, and it just is compelling from beginning to end.
Volume six and seven, the Return of the Shadow and the Treason of Isengard, you'll absolutely have a great time with them as I did. I really love seeing the evolution of the story.
I really love seeing the evolution of the story. I love seeing how things change. I love seeing how much he knew the full story kind of realized in his head and how much was not in there yet, how much he just kind of discovered as he wrote.










