Plant Based Bride 238K subscribers · Jan 8, 2026

The 10 Most Disappointing Books of 2025 👎 Don't believe the hype...

Reviews17

Liked

There were so many things I loved about Babel, but I did have quite a few critiques. There were quite a few things that didn't quite land for me or felt a little awkward or areas that I wished we'd explored more and other areas where she was a bit too heavy-handed, but the premise, the magic system, the themes, there were so many really special elements to that book that made me enjoy it despite my criticisms.

Disliked

I just found this book to be pretty lifeless, ironically, and boring, honestly, despite journeying through hell. The stakes were very low, the magic system was very underutilized, hell itself felt mostly like an empty void and not like a really interesting, fascinating place for us to explore and I could not stand our protagonist Alice whose internalized misogyny was completely out of control.

Loved

This touched me so deeply, and I thought it was gorgeous, just so perfectly put together, touched me on such a deep level, and there've been a handful of other novellas in this series that have made me feel similarly, but it just feels like the last two installments, especially, were rushed, or maybe McGuire's heart isn't in them anymore.