It felt meandering and purposeless, and the few themes that were interesting here just weren't explored to the depth that I've come to expect from this series and from Seanan McGuire, and it's really disappointing because I loved this series.
The 10 Most Disappointing Books of 2025 👎 Don't believe the hype...
- Biggest Disappointments of 2025 · 10 books · counted in creators' Biggest Disappointments of 2025
There were so many things I loved about Babel, but I did have quite a few critiques. There were quite a few things that didn't quite land for me or felt a little awkward or areas that I wished we'd explored more and other areas where she was a bit too heavy-handed, but the premise, the magic system, the themes, there were so many really special elements to that book that made me enjoy it despite my criticisms.
I didn't like how grief was handled in this book. I didn't like the romance. It didn't appeal to me.
I had read my first book from this author a little earlier in 2025 and absolutely loved it. I gave it five stars.
I thought the execution was so poor here. Lack of in-depth characterization, the lack of coherent and deep and thoughtful exploration of its themes.
I just found this book to be pretty lifeless, ironically, and boring, honestly, despite journeying through hell. The stakes were very low, the magic system was very underutilized, hell itself felt mostly like an empty void and not like a really interesting, fascinating place for us to explore and I could not stand our protagonist Alice whose internalized misogyny was completely out of control.
I read and loved Funny Story earlier this year.
Had some interesting ideas, but it didn't really take them anywhere, unfortunately. So, three stars for Graveyard Shift.
I read and adored Great Big Beautiful Life.
I loved If We Were Villains, gave it five stars, everything about it. It was like a book that was perfectly tailored for me and my interests.
Jane Eyre, not a romance.
There were too many characters. There were too many subplots. There were too many different elements vying for my attention and none of them got enough page time to really shine.
This touched me so deeply, and I thought it was gorgeous, just so perfectly put together, touched me on such a deep level, and there've been a handful of other novellas in this series that have made me feel similarly, but it just feels like the last two installments, especially, were rushed, or maybe McGuire's heart isn't in them anymore.
I did enjoy reading this book. I did find it funny at times and endearing. I liked our protagonist.
This book was such a slog. It was so frustrating for me to read. I felt like I was reading the same story told to me on repeat.
I think this book is still very good and I cried while reading it and I enjoyed my time reading it. I just think it's not nearly as polished of a product as Blood Over Bright Haven.
I had this with Wuthering Heights, not a romance.















