mynameismarines 40.5K subscribers · Dec 14, 2022

reading 30 books in 31 days: books #1-8 including Sea of Tranquility, Woman of Light and Out There

Reviews8

Loved

I found this absolutely fascinating I really loved this I love the stories in this I thought that they were each really well done like there were no stories that I was like that was really weak there were some standouts for me of course but nothing felt out of place it was tight it all came together

Loved

this one is like a very close second for my favorite in the entire series there's a line of continuity here that I really enjoy that comes over from the first book and there's so much thematically about light and dark but also about growing up and specifically about like growing apart from your friends or your friends heading off in different directions or having different Adventures than yours that just always absolutely breaks my heart in the most like wonderful tender way

Disliked

I didn't enjoy it very much either on first or second read it actually was trying to go for something like Fairyland land where it was more about characters and atmosphere and like a fairy tale esque Vibe darker than Fairyland for sure but still kind of that sort of atmosphere driven character-driven sort of work and because of that it didn't have a very strong plot core but it failed for me because I felt like the characters were incredibly flat there was absolutely no investment there for me they didn't feel like interesting or well fleshed out characters and then you had that weak plot on top of it that just brought it down to a really dull a really boring reading experience