Mike's Book Reviews 151K subscribers · Jan 8, 2026

My 10 Most Disappointing Books of 2025

Reviews22

Disliked

I went into this with the expectations of it was vampires versus werewolves. That was not the story that I was getting. So, I think early on I just said, you know, if that isn't what this is, I don't know if this is what I want to read right now.

Disliked

The politics and all the things going on behind the scenes, they were interesting. I didn't need that to be the bleed part of the story. And that's why Mocking Jay was kind of a wet fart for me in the end.

Loved

And I didn't feel like his books were doing that anymore, which was a far cry from My Best Friend's Exorcism, which just had so much heart and really just genuine good stuff in it that I really thought this was going to be the modern horror author I was looking for.

Liked

So, it had a lot of good in it, but after I read like Blackmouth and Bone White, I was like this, no, this is this is this is not what my expectations have now been set for a Ronald Mauie book and this didn't really hit them. Thankfully, that's probably my least favorite and it's still very good.

Disliked

Had the same problem with The Fisherman by John Langan. It's like the if you just written this as a period piece, it probably would have been really good. I didn't need that framing narrative.