MercysBookishMusings 40.4K subscribers · Feb 26, 2024

Women's Prize For Fiction Longlist Predictions

Reviews10

Disliked

Then I attempted to read Babel, didn't get very far in at all, read about 30 pages, felt like the writing was incredibly lacking in subtlety, felt like the author explained things to the readers that they didn't need to be explained, and yeah, I just didn't feel connected to the story at all.

Disliked

I've read quite a few Ann Patchett novels now and I was sort of convincing myself that I really loved Ann Patchett, but actually I've got to the point I reread Commonwealth recently which I'd remembered loving and I really didn't love it.

Liked

What made this novel really stand out for me is we so rarely get novels, , published in the UK by writers of color about characters of color living in a rural location, and that was very much at the heart of this novel, , about how the mother feels, how she's treated. , she's the only black person in the village, and she really struggles with, , the way in which she's so visible to everybody, and I think that was really well handled.

Loved

I really enjoyed this book. I think it's a real standout in terms of writing style and in terms of the things it makes you think about, but I think to me this book feels a bit too plotless for the Women's Prize and just it feels like it suits the Booker more.

Liked

But you can tell, as an adult reader, there's something slightly nefarious about this teacher, and things begin to escalate, and the novel is very tense and dark towards the end. And I just, yeah, I just feel like this is one that I could see a lot of different readers enjoying, so it feels like it would be a really good choice for the Women's Prize for me.

Disliked

I got maybe a third of the way through The Poppy War which is her debut novel I think and part of a trilogy and I found it compulsively readable but then it just started to feel really juvenile to me in terms of the decisions the characters were making and the plot felt a little all over the place and I ultimately DNF'd it.