Literature Science Alliance 10.6K subscribers · Oct 2, 2020

What are good Book Club Books? || Book Club Wrap Up and Recommendations || October 2020 [CC]

Reviews9

Liked

You might have seen it through a different person's perspective and at first it was really jarring because I would love every character I was with but then I’d never see them again, it was just so frustrating but I mean that's also a really great sign from an author. Like she had 20 pages for each character and I loved them all but also you could have picked up the breadcrumbs to kind of solve this mystery and in book club we were all discussing all those breadcrumbs so you came away being like oh my gosh I should have seen that I didn't realize that character was in this scene like because it was kind of confusing, like as a read it's not the most straightforward.

Liked

It was a really interesting nonfiction to read and because it was interesting and not like perfect we all had a lot to discuss there as well so yeah it was just like I said, we had a lot to unpack because we all had learned a lot and you know it's just it's really interesting so it was a really great book club read.

Loved

So it was a good book for reflection. I mean we are primarily a white book club so to read this story about the black struggle is you know we do tend to I feel do it pretty nuanced although there have definitely been times when like I said people don't understand that this is not the extreme this is the normal so in that way it was good but it was a very heavy read and I do think that the book is so good at getting its point across it doesn't leave as much room for discussion but it was a really great read, it was great for book club so I would pick it up.

Mixed

It was a lot of good discussion about different themes that I think were touched on, like my biggest complaint was that everything felt a little too surface level or maybe like one layer deep. Like you could have done more maybe focused on less you know focused in but we all got to talk about that and we talked for a very long time and yeah like I said that makes a great book club discussion right?

Loved

It's a book I wouldn't have picked up on my own, it was a book I enjoyed, it was a book that led to conversation, it was a book that inspired learning. I have a whole review on this book because it's so good but it's amazing for book clubs so I would pick it up if you know you guys want to explore maybe a Nigerian author, like this is amazing.

Mixed

Having that perspective but in general the portrayal of certain characters just was very like two-dimensional so we all had, we all had similar complaints and in general it just became a discussion about things we didn't like and we all thought it was like a three - two and a half star read, that was kind of our average.

Liked

Because I mean I wouldn't say Women Talking was the most enjoyable reading experience but it was an amazing book club experience. So my experience with that book is now better now because I had those discussions with these people and I got to have this better understanding because some people had historical context that we didn't have because they were curious about it or knew it.