I had read translation state this year, and I actually really liked it, even though I was very fine on Ancillary Justice.
Hugo 2024 Reactions
I mean, I love catfishing on catnip. I'm not mad.
And also, having read catfishing on catnip and chaos on catnip, which were both published by young adult and Prince, they are both young adult books, and I love them dearly.
Rose house with fifth place, which, honestly, I'm kind of glad about, because like, I really didn't like it
Fourth place is mimicking of known successes, which would have been my vote if I voted this year, which I did not. But I think mimicking of known successes was a stupid strong novella.
Stain of bright doors is fifth place? I think that's the one I would have put before Amina, then Amina al sarafi.
But some desperate glory is my favorite blend of entertaining sci fi, and especially because it's military sci fi, and I usually dislike military sci fi, but regardless, entertainment tropey genre fiction with some new conventions that are kind of slightly subversive on those tropes, and then with themes that you can engage with surface level. But it's also like it creeps up on you, and that's what happened to me with that book.
Starling house. It was high up here, which kind of makes sense people like Alex e Harrow in the Hugo space, but like, it was a fine book
There are places Amina al sarafi, I probably wouldn't put it that high up. I think I might have put one book before it, but like I liked it, it's fine.
I didn't finish that book, but I did like what it was doing.
Thorn hedge is not like that. Great of a book compared to, like, well, other novels on this another ti King Fisher in general.
I had read translation state this year, and I actually really liked it, even though I was very fine on Ancillary Justice.
Like, that's like, the ideal type of story to put in a novella space. That would have probably been my vote.
I've tried the water outlaws, and I deemed after them
And then, I guess, unless probably which King, because I don't think it just doesn't not deserve an award. I just didn't like the book.














