I didn't like this book. It was like a two star read, two and a half star read. I did not enjoy the main character.
How I voted || Hugo Ballot 2025
This is my least favorite of the novellas I read. I don't even think it was a headspace thing, because I read another novella right after it that I loved.
I adored a lot, and I've loved the short fiction by this author.
This is a perfect novella for me. A because if it was longer than a novella, it was longer than it currently is. I would hate it.
I don't think it's necessarily not worthy of awards. So I'm not like on ranking it. But I did DNF this book.
It's kind of gotten less good for me the further I get away from it. Not necessarily bad, it's just it was a four star and now it's a three and a half star.
And so again, the only four and a half star is a source comes to call by taking Fisher.
Somehow I put Ministry of Time above that, which is truly the most fine book I read in an incredibly long time. Three stars. Thematically, I don't think this sticks with me.
This is probably been elevated a tiny bit by how much I liked its sequel. And it's a cool world I like bumbling about in it. I think it's really interesting to look at.
I enjoyed this one a lot, and I think it was a story that worked really well in the novella format.
I liked it. I thought it was good. I don't think it should win this award.










