Library of a Viking 79.7K subscribers · May 8, 2026

The WORST First Books in Major Fantasy Series (New Reader Guide)

Reviews33

Loved

Now, way before Library of Viking was a thing, like three, four years before that, a humble little guy called Your Hand as Myself picked up A Song of Ice and Fire and I was absolutely overwhelmed by the page count, the complexity, the point of views, the politics, everything. Now, obviously, this series here is a masterpiece.

Loved

I adore this novel, but it is weird and trippy and it's set in a weird, mystical forest. You have these mythagas that are almost like these war characters and beings that come into play. It is wacky, weird.

Liked

I've actually become good friends with Ryan, but I read this book before I knew Ryan at all, and I thought it was great. Now, it is very, very, very derivative of Wheel of Time especially, but also a lot of other modern fantasy.

Disliked

My big issue with this novel is it didn't feel believable in any way. George, our protagonist, is like 13 years old and he is brightest human being almost in the whole world. I just I couldn't get into it.

Mixed

So, I actually didn't love Red Rising, the first book. One thing that you cannot criticize this book for isn't that it's definitely exciting. The writing style definitely sucks you in, so you're definitely able to imagine what's happening.

Loved

This book here in this series is one of the reasons why I fell in love with fantasy. I had never come across a hard magic system, and I just fell in love with it. And I just love an underdog, a heist story, and Vin is such a great, great character, and I just love the setup.

Mixed

That being said, The Gunslinger actually is one of the worst Stephen King books I have read. The thing with this series which is so weird is when you finished it, you really, really come to appreciate this book.

Loved

Now, the first book here, I love but it's almost like a whodunit crime thriller kind of story set in a fantasy world with some slight horror elements. And the later books then begin to go crazy when it comes to the horror elements. I think this is brilliant and the reason why I loved it is because it felt like it brought something new to the genre.

Disliked

This is actually a short story collection and if I'm being absolutely honest, I personally didn't really connect with it and I didn't think the short story collection, I don't know, I just didn't connect with it.

Loved

It might just be because I'm a huge sucker for a motley crew, underdogs, heist element kind of story, but it has all those things, and the writing is so beautiful and snappy and elegant. I just love this book. Truly one of the greatest books of all time.

Loved

But actually, The Poppy War was one of the first trilogies I read when I started getting into back into fantasy as an adult, and it was perfect. It has really great accessible writing style.

Mixed

I thought it reminded me a bit of John Gwynne's writing where you have a lot of action, a lot of action sequences, but I just didn't find it to be as good as John Gwynne's writing. And actually, after I read it, I didn't feel unfortunately that much motivation to actually continue.

Loved

This book is chunky, 1,100 pages, and all the five books are in this universe are huge, huge, huge, but it has that accessible writing that makes it a bit easier, I think, to recommend to someone that isn't an avid reader but doesn't really know that much about epic fantasy.