Library of a Viking 79.7K subscribers · Jun 8, 2026

The Complete Fantasy Guide for Every Reader

Reviews23

Loved

What an amazing book. Don't get me wrong, Realm of the Elderlings, the whole series, has very complicated world building when you go deeper into it. But, the first book alone is quite focused on just a couple locations.

Loved

Now, I think that this is one of the greatest novels I have ever read. It's one of the greatest novels ever written. It is a masterpiece and I can't even believe that David Mitchell pulled this off.

Disliked

I really, really want to love Malazan Book of the Fallen, but I just struggle because the world-building is so dense and the plot structure is so complicated. It's so hard to know who to root for, who to follow, and just to remember who is who is just crazy.

Loved

Very similar to Brandon Sanderson, John Gwynne has this incredibly accessible writing style, but he has short chapters which just really eases you in. But his world isn't the most simple one and also his plot structure does jump between POVs.

Loved

Now, the later books might get a bit more complicated, but as entry points into fantasy, I think these are amazing. They don't get too heavy on the world building. The writing is really, really strong and this plot structure, yeah, it's not all that simple.

Loved

That being said, this is one of the most unique worlds I've seen with some of the greatest animal creatures, some really, really cool dragons. And when you're able to push yourself and actually get into this novel, it is so, so satisfying and brilliant.

Disliked

I have read around half of this novel, and I gave up because it is so complicated. It's almost written like a mythology, like a creation story, and it does not follow a normal plot structure as it's more like a short story collection, and we know that a lot of Silmarillion wasn't really finished.