Library of a Viking 79.7K subscribers · Nov 8, 2024

YouTube Picked My Books For A Year: Here's What Happened

Reviews13

Mixed

It genuinely felt like Stephen King wrote two almost separate stories and combined them and you got the mess that was fairy tale first half incredible second half absolutely rubbish

Loved

this novel has become one of my alltime favorite novels and you know what's so interesting this is a Sci-Fi a genre I generally really struggle with first and foremost what makes this novel incredible is that while it has so many fascinating sci-fi concept the main driver behind this novel is really the characters Incredible characters

Disliked

I read it and I ended up giving it two stars now I recently met Nicholas e the author of this book at worldcon and he was the loveliest human being I've ever met and he had seen my review I literally posed a review to my channel where I kind of discussed that I didn't really get the hype for this book

Loved

while it does maybe have some pacing issues in places as a whole I was utterly captivated by the story it has an incredible villain and just the overal concept of a random mysterious guy coming to a small town opening up a shop where people can come in and get a wish or something that their hearts desire but then it comes at a great cost just that concept is so brilliant

Mixed

when I finished this novel it kept staying with me there were so many interesting themes about like identity religion especially and just critique of governments and capitalism and so many interesting things that while I didn't really enjoy my reading experience with the novel I ended up being so glad that I actually had read it

Mixed

while I found a lot of the aspect in this novel to be very fascinating for example the World building that were set it has some Greek inspiration which I'm not sure if I read that many fantasy novels that has like Greek inspiration to it and it also has a lot of the elements that I love in fantasy like a coming of age a lot of politics a lot of big battles and so on and while I was reading it I wasn't really sure why I just didn't feel overly connected with the characters

Disliked

after page 150 it just became too much it was just like every single sentence is just a massive joke or just some like so many absurd things happened in this novel I think this might be the lowest rated novel I read since I launched my book club

Loved

this is like proper incredible Epic Fantasy with Incredible politics fascinating World building and it's just a beautiful slowburn yes this novel takes his time to get to this place but when you finally get to the climax the whole journey has definitely been worth it absolutely love it

Liked

what I loved was the World building I thought our protagonist was a very interesting character and yeah there was a lot of actions a lot of training sequences and the overarching plot was great now my biggest issue with this novel was that there was just too much focus on the training sequences and that I just found the protagonist to be too focused on Revenge