lexi aka newlynova 350K subscribers Β· Nov 8, 2025

24 books in 24 minutes. just kidding it’s 2 hours πŸš‚

Reviews27

Mixed

June's relationship with her dad in this book actually made me cry. There's like one section in particular in the middle that I thought was really beautiful and just the complex feelings that June is experiencing grieving this person who was kind of a hero to her but who was a hero with a really complicated legacy. All of that was really good.

Disliked

I ended up giving it 2.5 stars. I do have memories of not hating everything about this book. I do remember thinking it was well paced and appreciating also that the main character, I think in general, in Jillian Flynn books, the way that she writes women who kind of suck is really compelling to me.

Mixed

It's definitely I think my least favorite Ali Hazelwood novel that I've read. Not because it was bad. I mean, tonally Ali Hazelwood books to this day, even with this one, they're like so consistent.

Disliked

But yeah, I mean I gave it 2.5 stars, which it lost half a star for the usual rating that I give books that are like kind of inoffensively forgettable just because it was it was that forgettable. It truly just felt like time I could have spent doing absolutely anything else.

Loved

I picked up this book because I really liked Jillian Flynn's other two books, Gone Girl and Sharp Objects. Those are both like top 10 mystery thrillers to me, so I assumed that this would also be a slam dunk.

Liked

I gave it four stars. I don't think that really captures my full opinion on the reading experience. But at the end of the day, I do feel like I took a lot from the story and the way that it like infected me in my thoughts when I was reading it.

Liked

I feel like this is one of the closest YA romances to that particular feeling of like being at a sleepover with your friends and you turn on some kind of teen movie that they just they don't make them like that anymore because for better and for worse we've moved on from the early 2000s and it also did carry with it I think some of the common flaws that teen movies also have. But overall I definitely enjoyed it and I could absolutely see myself reading some more of this author's work especially since I feel like a lot of her other books are also very beloved inside of the romance space.

Liked

But yeah, I did like it overall. I thought it was really interesting. I particularly liked the main character's journey and her experiences of loneliness and difference from all of the other people inside of her community just because they don't really have a shared language of experience to communicate with.

Liked

I did still like it overall. Absolutely. For me personally, it was for sure worth my while, but my opinion on it has gone down a little bit just because I think what's really sticking in my memory are the things that I wish were better.

Loved

It comfortably peaks, I would say, at the level of testosterone that you see exhibited in stories like Project Hail Mary and The Will of the Many. Those I can get behind. I [ __ ] love those books, even if they're a little bit man.

Loved

I picked up this book because I really liked Jillian Flynn's other two books, Gone Girl and Sharp Objects. Those are both like top 10 mystery thrillers to me, so I assumed that this would also be a slam dunk.

Loved

And because the characterization in this book individually is so strong, their relationship is so good, the banter is so good, the conversations that they have, and just like with First- time Caller, the greater cast of side characters is also super duper likable, even when they don't get a lot of page time. The way that they're written makes them feel like people, which is just it's a gift that some authors have, I think.