Kalanadi 11.8K subscribers · Mar 22, 2021

March 2021 Reading Wrap-Up #2

Reviews17

Disliked

it felt like it was really style over substance there wasn't enough clarity i didn't understand enough of what had happened by the end for it to be satisfying so it's got this really lush beautiful prose

Mixed

the short version here is that i enjoyed these but they're not my favorite things by diana and jones by any means they're definitely for younger readers and two of them are more like story collections which were a little bit more hit and miss for me

Loved

volume 17 was so much better mostly because decent things happen in the plot and the artwork was great it seemed like a return to decent writing the characters were getting along there were secondary characters who reappeared and i really enjoyed them

Loved

i really enjoyed this it was good fun i devoured the entire thing in two days it's almost 500 pages long my only criticism of this book and the reason why i didn't give it a good solid five stars is that the middle part felt stodgy

Disliked

i didn't think it was funny and i didn't understand what it was talking about because i probably lacked a ton of context to understand the references the illusions the jokes the metaphors the analogies instead what it read like to me was this really bizarre almost surrealist weird story it didn't make any sense

Mixed

the short version here is that i enjoyed these but they're not my favorite things by diana and jones by any means they're definitely for younger readers and two of them are more like story collections which were a little bit more hit and miss for me