Gavin Reads It All 134K subscribers Β· Feb 8, 2026

My Spreadsheet Randomiser Picks My Read It or Unhaul It TBR πŸ“š Emboss or Toss Vlog

Reviews11

Liked

I gave it four stars. I really enjoyed it. I'm very excited for the sequel, and hopefully I can get a chance to read that as soon as possible, but there was lots of subverting expectations in this book where you would think a lot of it would be quite generic, but it actually worked for me.

Disliked

I did listen to the entirety of the audiobook for the passengers on the Hankyu line and I wasn't the biggest fan of this and I did actually go back a couple of chapters cause when I first started listening to it I couldn't pay attention too much so I slowed the speed down to 1.8, which is rather slowish for me. And I went back a couple of chapters and I listened to it again as I was playing Breath of the Wild. And I just I just didn't like I found it so boring.

Mixed

I have finished The Secret History and I'll give it like 2.5 stars. I was locked in from pages like 200 to 450. There's a really good chunk of things happening during that time and it made the story like really exciting to follow and I love seeing the characters squirm.

Disliked

I am 211 pages in and not only am I pretty much bored out of my mind, but I don't really think I like the main character all that much and I don't really like following her story. And the plot is still showing how it is very similar to a lot of other plots in thrillers of, you know, a child who's gone through some trauma and there's a new nanny that's been brought in and that nanny now has to navigate these new secrets of the family. But yeah, I just I don't think I care anymore.