i think that ve schwab in the third book may have spent perhaps a little bit too much time kind of prepping for future things
FANTASY TRILOGIES VS FANTASY DUOLOGIES
i really just think that this would have been best as a standalone or executed a little bit differently
i actually think i enjoyed the trilogy as a whole
i loved the characters in the first book and i liked the side characters aside characters i don't know that i wanted to focus on them in the next book as much
in the second book i think that it would have it could have been written as one story but then you would have had a very major this amount of time later so it needed to be two books
the first book was a satisfying story it was fun it was very exploration centered as kind of a traveling story with a fun setting and i liked the characters
the second book is my favorite is there a little bit of a tone shift kinda but i think i think done very well because there's things set up at the end of the first book that lead you to be craving those in the second which we got which i loved
is the ending of the second one satisfying yes
however the second book i really did not think that book was necessary
i really enjoyed the setting it was quite foresty and outdoors because she's a tracker
then the third book i just i mean i feel like the meanderingness of this series it kind of ends up hurting it a little bit in the end
you get introduced to some new things in the second book that when you're first introduced to them you're like what is this who are these people why am i here and then once you kind of see how it all comes together it's actually i think quite brilliant
i think that the ending was very much the ending which i very much enjoyed
when i got into the second one there were just some things that i felt like were a little bit of fluff didn't necessarily need to be there
i've read this twice through and i never really can quite distinguish the books apart from one another so that tone shift that can sometimes happen there's aspects that change throughout the story but i think it's a very cohesive change
did i like the ending yes did i like that first book yes
we get so much character focus we see their trauma explored we see how that affects how they are we see the relationships between these characters
you don't focus in as much on a certain character that i loved and as a result i miss that absolutely in that second book that's part of why i think that second book is a little bit weaker
i think this one very much feels like a fairy tale and so it's very whimsical and i would say slightly meandering
this one i love this story but this could not have been any more of a let's just cut it in the middle kind of an ending this one is one of the least satisfying cliffhangers ever
the first book it just it just happens and you're like that's definitely not all the story and so you keep going because there's basically no plot in the first one
the first one left me intrigued enough to keep going and i think it did a good job of setting up the fact that we were gonna get more
i personally found when i read the first one the first time because i have read this more than once but when i read the first time i enjoyed the first book it was that additional time with these characters that really made me fall in love with them
i do think that the whole beginning middle end every time i feel like sanderson upped it to the point that by the end we were talking the most intense stakes imaginable
ultimately i was kind of disappointed with the third one only because of the general feel of the ending which i can't describe because i feel like even describing the feel of the ending as a spoiler
the first book is kind of a heist we gotta try to take down the bad guy type of story and then the second one it's a lot of maneuvering and trying to establish policies and laws and then siege tactics and things like that which i ate up but it's very different than the first one
i loved the second one because i liked all the scheming
it's a fascinating setup as are most of ve schwab's stories i think it could have been one longer very interesting book
i was nervous reading a part of that second book when i was starting it but then it started to really get going it brought it home
i actually enjoyed the second one even more i liked getting to see the other characters i think that she did her timeline fiasco again really well because it's a fractured timeline
the first book is almost so satisfying in its ending that the next one can just feel like an add-on




























