It's very generous and expensive and it's also quite soulful as he kind of delves into life lessons from the great Russian short story writers, while at the same time, of course, unpacking what works about their short stories and how to replicate that or at least to attempt to replicate that in one's own writing.
You Don’t Need a Creative Writing Degree to Write Brilliant Books
He really is able to harmonize some really beautiful reflections, both literary and personal, into this condensed form of three or four pages. So, there's a lot to learn from it, and it's also Orner's a really friendly and heartwarming book, like I said.
Some of his ideas have really stood the test of time even if they are at times sort of parodied by later proponents of fiction writing, most famously of course his idea of flat characters and round characters, but I still think there's a lot to be gleaned from this book and even from that notion of round characters that have a psychological and an aesthetic fullness
It is a little bit outdated in that it talks about sending letters via the mail or submissions via mail. And that's a practice that is almost completely obsolete now. It's pretty much all done via platforms like Submittable or just through email. but nonetheless, it's very simple in its approach and there's definitely lessons to be gleaned from it.
The four novellas that make up Old New York, for example get your hands on those. They are scintillating and scalpel-sharp examples of pitch-perfect fiction writing.
This book is a lovely meld of both craft writing, but also memoir itself. I think she does that exceptionally well.
Now, this book is it's got an austerity to it. She's a little bit haughty. It's also bracing because she doesn't beat around the bush.
But regardless of that one quibble, the good stuff within this book is still absolutely worth the money and it's it's a good guide to writing essays.
So, it's kind of slanted and goofy at times, but also very original, and it's just a different take on a book of craft. I recommend this if you want to hone your poetics.








