Bren Booth-Jones | Folio & Tome 54.4K subscribers · Nov 8, 2025

When Brilliant Writers Publish Terrible Books

Reviews19

Disliked

Yeah, it's very tepid both times through. I think what is what is a pity about a Mercy especially again in comparison to Beloved Home Jazz, The Blest Eye and Song of Solomon is that it's a slim novel, but it doesn't really have cohesion in my opinion.

Disliked

But, , it's a battlefield is like that sounds combative. It sounds, you know, that there's some kind of force and resolute friction that we're going to encounter in this novel, but it's just dusty and grimy and cold and windswept and it doesn't really repay much in terms of readerly satisfaction.

Disliked

The character himself, Jim, is just so precious and misunderstood and gloomy and moody, but all of those traits of his, he's just brattish and selfobsessed. So, the narrator is actually Marlo, same character as the narrator of Heart of Darkness. and Marlo, the book functions because Marlo is like so fascinated by Jim, but I just don't find Jim fascinating.

Loved

Now, I absolutely love A Christmas Carol, of course, and I love The Chimes. I've talked about the chimes on this channel before as well, but The Haunted Man is the is the third of those three Christmas novellas.