Now, I absolutely love A Christmas Carol, of course, and I love The Chimes.
When Brilliant Writers Publish Terrible Books
Yeah, it's very tepid both times through. I think what is what is a pity about a Mercy especially again in comparison to Beloved Home Jazz, The Blest Eye and Song of Solomon is that it's a slim novel, but it doesn't really have cohesion in my opinion.
And I also have some of his like late reflections, kind of memoirish books, like a sort of life that I found to be quite lacking in vigor, but we're going to forgive him those as well.
I'm not going to talk about Alme's Folly, which I think is a steaming pile of folly, but it's his first novel, so we're going to leave that out.
Covert Joy is a is an absolutely sublime, mesmerizing collection of stories. There is not one false note across those 10 or 12 stories.
Heart of Darkness in all of its troubled doubleness and spookiness, and it's obviously flawed in many ways, but it is an astounding and idiosyncratic work of literature.
But, , it's a battlefield is like that sounds combative. It sounds, you know, that there's some kind of force and resolute friction that we're going to encounter in this novel, but it's just dusty and grimy and cold and windswept and it doesn't really repay much in terms of readerly satisfaction.
The character himself, Jim, is just so precious and misunderstood and gloomy and moody, but all of those traits of his, he's just brattish and selfobsessed. So, the narrator is actually Marlo, same character as the narrator of Heart of Darkness. and Marlo, the book functions because Marlo is like so fascinated by Jim, but I just don't find Jim fascinating.
I haven't read all of his books, but some of his novels are really serenely beautiful such as Norwegian Wood and another lesserknown novel of his which is South of the Border, West of the Sun.
But Salomi I just think it's so feverish in an unappealing way. It's so sort of ornate in its biblical illusions and its sensuousness. It feels over rich.
It's a slim, spare, ruminative, delicate book interlaced with yearning in a in a very gorgeous way.
Now, I absolutely love A Christmas Carol, of course, and I love The Chimes. I've talked about the chimes on this channel before as well, but The Haunted Man is the is the third of those three Christmas novellas.
Now, this is about there about seven or eight story collections in this in this book by the Brazilian 20th century modernist Clarissa Spectre. It's quite an uneven collection.
I'm giving him a pass on players like the Duchess of Padua which is definitely him finding his finding his voice and but it's it's quite forgettable as well.
And The Haunted Man doesn't come off for me because it is overly sweet. It is sentimental, heading rapidly south towards Mlin. And it's very moralistic.
The Hound of the Basks is the best of these hands down in my opinion. It's spectral and spooky and deliciously eerie.
But the sign of four is by far the most disappointing of these. I found it to be extraordinarily dated. It's quite offensive in its cultural stereotypes.
It is literally and figuratively masturbatory and it's just it's just a waste of time really. It's it feels like Roth is just basically having us on.
But I found this to be banal, shallow, a sense of being a sketch. And maybe even in that sense, we can say a sketchiness to it. It doesn't hold together.


















