BooksandLala 163K subscribers · Aug 16, 2026

Finding 5⭐ Horror from a Decade Ago

Reviews18

Black mad wheelJosh Malerman
Not a fan

I got 120 pages in and I have to give up. I just don't feel like anything that interesting is actually happening, and I'm so incredibly bored.

I liked it and so technically it's going in here even though it's only a four-star. Her writing is stunning in here and I think being 182 pages, like she's just really good at description. I just thought it was really well done and I had a good time.

Like I didn't love Mexican Gothic. I don't love Rebecca. They're good, like they're three-star reads, but it takes a little something extra to make me absolutely love a gothic novel.

PenpalDathan Auerbach
Loved it

I read Penpal about a month ago now and it really surprised me because it's one of those books that I feel like I saw people pitch as maybe really gratuitous or really gruesome or maybe there was some type of comp given for it that sounded like extreme horror to me. And maybe not pick up Penpal for the longest time and then I finally had to and it was so good.

RebeccaDaphne du Maurier
Mixed

Like I didn't love Mexican Gothic. I don't love Rebecca. They're good, like they're three-star reads, but it takes a little something extra to make me absolutely love a gothic novel.

The ChangelingVictor D. LaValle
Loved it

It was kind of like three different narratives all happening at the same time... and he kept me on my toes. it kind of felt like a fever dream that was really fun. Think we call it a four and we pop it in there.

It was definitely gross, like one of the most descriptively uncomfortable, gory scenes with these children. So, would recommend for that. Would still definitely recommend. It's not going to be above a four. It might be a 3.75.

The WarrenUnknown
Mixed

And we found another a three-star for the video. This was fine. It was another book about recovering memories or kind of the attempt to do so. But at the end of the day, I just didn't really like the writing of it. I didn't like the head that we were in.

The Winter BoxTim Waggoner
Not a fan

It was weird. It was kind of a fever dream, and I was having an interesting time, and then it got so much so quickly. So much about sex, and this guy couldn't stop talking about his dick like so aggressively much.

Thin AirMichelle Paver
Loved it

I love books about obsession and I would almost say this is kind of that because the fear that this man feels is an obsession of its own. I would definitely recommend this one. I think it holds up.

Unbury CarolJosh Malerman
Loved it

And what happened to me with Unbury Carol is it sat in my TBR closet for years, and then I put it off and put it off. And when I finally got to it, I loved it.