I think I found volume one like a bit too pulled back for me, but once we got into volume two and volume three and we're sort of following the characters in a more detailed way, I really, really enjoyed it. I thought there were some really powerful moments in here and I always sort of love the way Margaret Oliphant writes and pulls you into the story.
October Reading Wrap Up | Victober Reads
I thought there were some fantastic moments in this book. George Gissing writes like he has a really good like eye for a really dramatic scene and there were some like absolutely incredible moments in this. There were some great characterization as well, especially Adela and Emma Vine were really well characterized.
So I sort of in some way absolutely loved Diana of the Crossways, but I also found it not the easiest read and so not the most compelling read, but I do think it had some fantastic moments and some really, really interesting themes and characters. So slightly mixed thoughts, but like pretty broadly positive.
I find the characterization quite weak and the female characters bother me and it's just overall it's just really not a book for me.
Wouldn't be my absolutely favorite by Margaret Oliphant. Hester would still definitely be that.
In the War of the Sea is just the paciest Victorian novel I have ever read. It is so dramatic. It is such a page turner.
I thought it was good fun, you know, a sort of swashbuckling adventure story about this young boy called Davie in Scotland who ends up going on sort of all kinds of adventures. I enjoyed it more than Treasure Island, which is the other sort of book of the same genre by Robert Louis Stevenson that I've read. but I didn't absolutely love it.
This book is exquisite, and I just I cried so much. I thought it was so utterly beautiful.
I feel like the genre of Victorian adventure for teenagers basically, , is not like my absolute favorite genre, but for what this book is, I thought it was really fun and I thought it worked well, , and yeah, I had a good time with it.
I generally quite enjoyed The Clocks. I thought it was good fun and quite interesting. I really like the setup.
And those sort of spooky stories that people tell them, , were very effective, I thought, and worked really well, , but it does mean that it's a slightly like it's a slight bit of a hodgepodge of a book, I suppose, because these characters are sort of going on a journey and meeting people who tell them stories, and I feel like that works in a longer book, but in a book that's very short feels a bit odd.
It is very silly and very fun, but also sort of has a fair bit of heart and the sort of love story running through it. I thought it was quite nicely handled, so although it is sort of mostly silly swashbuckling fun, I do feel like it had some emotional moments and it did that quite well too.
And it's just a really interesting, really atmospheric read that tells you quite a lot about like Victorian society and Victorian fears especially to do with like evolution and devolution.
I really enjoyed The White Company. I would say that I liked the first half more than the second.
I think it's worth knowing before going into this book that it is a deeply racist book, both in the sense of like there being lots of racist language and people saying things that are, you know, very difficult to read, but also the sort of premise of the book I think is bound up with racist ideas. So I think that's worth knowing going into it, , but for all that I do think it's a very sort of historically interesting book, , and it's also a very sort of pacey read.
so yeah not a new favorite Gissing like The Odd Women and The Nether World would still rate way above Demos for me.
so yeah not a new favorite Gissing like The Odd Women and The Nether World would still rate way above Demos for me.
I think it's a great read with some really interesting characterization and the dramatic climax is really fantastic. I do think though that there are quite a lot of loose ends, which isn't something I really spotted on my first read.
















