Book Roast 91.8K subscribers · Jan 17, 2026

🏆 Annual Book Awards: The Best and Worst Reads of 2025

  • Best of 2025 · 8 books · counted in creators' Best of 2025
  • Biggest Disappointments of 2025 · 2 books

Reviews10

Battle royaleKōshun Takami
Not a fan

I didn't DNF and I finished it and I actually do regret not DNFing it because it did not get better for me. I hoped that it would and it would be like worth it at the end, but it was not.

BewitchedLori Foster
Loved it

I loved this book. It was such a brilliant time. It was just very cozy, very heartwarming, just beautiful, genuinely just fantastic.

CinderMarissa Meyer
Loved it

Despite that, this actually is not a new release at all and it's Cinder, earlier YA sci-fi at least retellings, and this one was just a really nice surprise. Not that I didn't expect to like it, but I was going in cautiously.

It did take me a tiny bit to get into it and I think the first 20-30% was perhaps why it didn't quite reach five stars. Other than that though, it has been such a highlight of my reading year this year.

The Spear Cuts Through Water and I will add a caveat that I understand this is a piece of art, but it's so poetic and it's so artistic it's hard for me to digest. For me, particularly as a reader, as a person, it's not my style. Again, I didn't make very far into this. It was a DNF.

but the one that actually I loved so much and ended up being one of my favorite books of this year was The Black Obelisk. It is dense, not an easy read I would say. However, it is also humorous in a satirical way, which I also historically really mesh well with.