Words in Time 19.3K subscribers · Oct 5, 2022

You Voted for 4 Hugo Award Winners and I Ranked Them

Reviews4

Mixed

overall I think the city and the city had a few really intriguing elements and I'm sure there are going to be people that love this book especially if they're into contemporary literature urban fantasy murder mystery but for me as a Sci-Fi writer there was just a lot in this book that really didn't click for me in the end I'm gonna have to give this one a 5 out of 10.

Mixed

so overall I think there are a few really good ideas in this book there were just a couple of elements that didn't quite click for me and it didn't quite build to what I thought it potentially could have for me the demolished man was a six and a half out of ten so I was a little mixed there

Mixed

so this is a bit of a tough one to score because we've gone from the city and the city to A Tale of Two Cities or at least a tale of two halves because I was really enjoying the first half of this book and then I felt a little underwhelmed by the second half

Loved

I don't really have any dislikes for weigh station if I had to nitpick I guess I could say that the plot progression could have been a little bit more exciting and simack could have maybe pushed some of the Sci-Fi Concepts a little bit further but that wasn't what this book was really about I feel like in this book simack was going for atmosphere and the thoughts and the ideas and I think he really achieved both of those in terms of creating a very specific tone and creating a really thought-provoking novel however a full-length review for this one if you're interested but spoiler alert I loved it nine out of 10.