With Ali 31.5K subscribers · Jan 13, 2026

the worst & most disappointing books I read in 2025 (& what NOT to add to your tbr)

  • Biggest Disappointments of 2025 · 18 books

Reviews20

Doesn't hold the same impact as the first one. I feel like there was things that were put in it simply for shock value and not because they actually needed to happen. Kind of reverses a lot of the things and consequences that happened within the first one as well.

I tend to love Emily Henry, but this one was such a dud. I think Emily Henry was trying to do something different and it didn't go well because so much of her reader base is based in keeping things very similar.

Hate MailUnknown
Not a fan

DNFed this because it was going in a really creepy direction and I looked up reviews cuz I was like, is this where I think it was going? And it sure was. And I was like, I ain't down with that because seemed a little non-consensual in terms

Jade CityFonda Lee
Not a fan

I got at least 25% of the way through this and just was I just didn't like it. I don't I don't really care for the world. I felt like it was just really slowgoing.

There were some standout moments in this where I was like, 'This is really cool.' Like, I like this world building. I like these characters, but at the end of the day, like, there just wasn't enough compelling content to just keep me going.

Thursday Murder Club was just so boring. So boring. I really thought that we were going to get like oldie solving a murder, but man, we are just down into the nittygritty of like old these people in this like retirement home just like making up drama and getting into I just didn't care.